MAXWELL: Short of the promise
9/26/1999 – Printed in the PERSPECTIVE section of the St Petersburg Times Newspaper
Ethiopian Jews who were part of a mass immigration to Israel _ the Promised Land _ in the 1980s and ’90s still struggle to assimilate. Failed educational strategies, a cultural gap between young and old, and questions of racism stand in the way of a people in search of an identity.
During the early 1980s, the state of Israel, barely 30 years old, embarked on one of the boldest experiments in social, cultural and religious engineering attempted by any other nation in modern history. It began the immigration of the entire population of black Ethiopian Jews to its shores.
Almost everyone agrees that this mass aliyah (“to go up,” or to immigrate to Israel) was an unparalleled undertaking. In flights that took less than two hours from sites in Ethiopia to Tel Aviv, thousands of Ethiopian Jews were literally transported from a world of agricultural villages to a modern, industrialized democracy.
So, after nearly two decades in the Promised Land, how well are the black Jews coping? How well are they, as Israeli authorities call this process, “absorbing” into Israeli life? Are these immigrants, like others before them _ the Polish, the Yemenis, the Moroccans, the Russians _ becoming Israeli?
I went to Israel in May to answer these questions for myself.
Arriving at Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion International Airport on May 4, I saw the following headline on the front page of the English edition of Ha’aretz, a major daily newspaper: “Soldier killed by bomb in Lebanon; tracker wounded.” The accompanying photograph was that of the dead soldier, a handsome Ethiopian Jew named Molo Nagato.
Nowhere did the article say that Nagato was Ethiopian. He was called Staff Sargeant Nagato. The 80-kilogram charge that killed him was planted by Hezbollah, a Lebanese political-religious group at war with Israel.
His death pointed to an obvious beginning. To start my research, I wanted to know how well Nagato had fared in the tough Israel Defense Forces. How well had this Ethiopian “absorbed” into the ranks? After all, military service anchors all of Israeli life.
I telephoned the Givati Brigade, the dead soldier’s unit, and explained what I wanted. Top brass usually cooperate with the foreign press, but after I mentioned Nagato’s race, the spokesperson’s voice went cold. “Staff Sargeant Molo Nagato was a soldier,” the man on the line said. “And a Jew. We don’t treat Ethiopians any different than we treat anyone else in the Givati Brigrade. Everyone is a soldier.”
Was he telling the truth? I wanted to know.
In her recently published book, Hachi Achi (Best Brother), author Malka Shabtai, an anthropologist at Ben-Gurion University near Tel Aviv, studied what she calls “the search for identity among Ethiopian immigrant soldiers.” An IDF veteran, Shabtai focused on the first Ethiopians drafted into the military following Operation Moses, the huge airlift of Ethiopian Jews to the Promised Land in 1984. The study does not deal with immigrants who arrived during or after Operation Solomon in 1991.
“By making aliyah, this first generation realized a dream, the yearning for Jerusalem nurtured since childhood,” Shabtai writes. “The sense of accomplishment is very powerful and has great meaning for the way they see themselves in Israeli society. But realizing this dream has also exacted a heavy psychological price. Adjustment difficulties and being separated from one’s past and family are only part of it. The real breaking point was discovering that although they had reached the Promised Land, reuniting with the Jewish people and living as equals remained an elusive goal.”
By most measures and because of affirmative action, Ethiopian Jews have prospered in the army. They are highly motivated, and what is perceived as their natural gentleness makes them obedient stalwarts who follow orders without question. Out of gratitude for being in Israel and from the need to prove themselves worthy, many Ethiopians volunteer for elite infantry units.
For all of the benefits they receive, however, many Ethiopians acknowledge discrimination in the IDF. None, for example, have been promoted beyond the rank of major, and a disproportionately high number wind up as border guards. Other soldiers call them “an Ethiopian ghetto.” Depending on who is believed _ the army or independent research _ the suicide rate among Ethiopians is much higher than that of other soldiers.
Many Ethiopians, along with military observers, also believe that military life often reinforces stereotypes of Ethiopians. The notion that they cannot get ahead in Israel’s aggressive culture tends to be reaffirmed, for instance, by the very traits _ their willingness to obey _ that make them good soldiers.
But the litmus test on how well these soldiers have been absorbed becomes clear after they return to civilian life, where they become just like other Ethiopian Jews. Several indicators are not encouraging.
“Our soldiers have it good in the army,” said Uri Tamiat, 30, executive director of the Israel Association for Ethiopian Jews. “After their release, the Israelis go back to their families and their comfortable lives. They fly off to the Far East. Ethiopian soldiers return to the cycle of poverty, ghetto life and a feeling of impotence. …
“What’s the good of being an officer or winning a citation of excellence from the chief of staff once you’re out of the army? These soldiers give everything they’ve got and think they’ve proven themselves. Then disappointment hits, and that is what they bequeath to their younger brothers and sisters.”
Seeking an identity
These “younger brothers and sisters” are at the core of the Ethiopian Jewish dilemma. To one degree or another, most Israelis, especially public officials, are worried about these youngsters _ the “second generation,” those under 18 years of age who make up more than half of the nearly 70,000 Ethiopian Jewish population.
Many in this group, some born in Israel, are well-adjusted, have friends outside their segregated communities and are earning good grades in school. But thousands of others, mostly males, do not want to join the army, are doing poorly in school or have dropped out and do not get along with their parents.
I found many of these teenagers at the Central Bus Station in Tel Aviv, a grim, sprawling labyrinth of concrete, steel and glass that has come to symbolize Israel’s failure to absorb these young people.
Here, the children hang out, many having run away from home. Some rent cheap apartments with friends or live on the streets, where they commit petty crimes or deal drugs to survive. Many government and non-government organizations struggle to help these children adjust to Israeli life. Some officials acknowledge, however, that they are fighting an uphill battle against the allure of the bus station culture, the nearby fast-food joints and the reggae nightclubs, such as the Soweto and The House, hugging the Mediterranean shore.
Reality tells us that most of these kids are thoroughly disenchanted. They are fed up with their government-sponsored boarding schools, where they are forced to live away from home and are virtually segregated from their veteran Israeli peers. School for these kids is one more Ethiopian ghetto in the Promised Land. Many also are angry at their parents or are ashamed of their parents’ traditional practices and manners. Correctly or not, these adolescents dislike almost everything about Israel.
Their coping mechanism?
They turn to the West _ to the United States and to the West Indies _ in an attempt to find an identity they can call their own. On most weekday nights, especially on Thursday before the Jewish Sabbath, hundreds of these youngsters can be seen sporting dreadlocks and other smart hairdos, earrings and hip baggy attire in and around the bus station.
Although the overwhelming majority have never met an African-American, they are avid viewers of MTV and other venues trading the hip-hop melange. Whenever a rap or reggae concert comes to the Holy Land, Ethiopian kids attend in packs.
Not surprisingly, experts say, the crime rate among Ethiopian children is skyrocketing, and street gangs are even appearing in a few cities far from the urban centers of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem.
“These kids have reached the point where they are trying to find out where they are,” said Yossi Mengistu, in an interview with the Jerusalem Post. Mengistu headed a youth information center for the Israel Association for Ethiopian Jews in the Central Bus Station. “They think they may have come to the wrong address. So they start looking for another identity, neither Israeli nor Ethiopian. Perhaps Afro-American or Jamaican. They identify with the members of these communities because they are looking for people who are in similar straits, that live in the same distress and also suffer discrimination.”
Eden Tasfay, a 20-year-old resident of the coastal city of Hadera and who recently completed military service, understands the difficulties Ethiopian teens face throughout Israel. She wants to become a teacher to be a role model for the next generation.
“The young generation, most of them, cannot relate to the older Ethiopians,” Eden said. “Nearly all of the older ones still speak Amharic (the native language of Ethiopian Jews in the Gonder region of Ethiopia). In the adult clubs, the music is in Amharic. The kids say, “God, I don’t need that. I want to see Biggie Smalls.’ Even though Biggie is dead. Believe it or not, young Ethiopian Jews still believe that Tupac Shakur is alive. They love the American rappers and the Rastafarians. …
“Without the clubs, young Ethiopians don’t have much to do. You get tired of staying home and listening to records all the time; tired of your mama nagging you all the time to watch your sister; tired of sharing a bedroom with, like, seven brothers; tired of cleaning the house; tired of being asked who are “these best friends’ you’re hanging out with; tired of the boarding schools; tired of everything. Pretty soon, these kids start acting like gang-bangers.”
Social humiliation
Ethiopian elders, along with government officials, are clearly worried that the young people are becoming Westernized so quickly _ and so thoroughly. Unless someone finds a way to connect them to the Israeli esprit, the young will continue to bear the burdens of being immigrants in a strict religious culture that initially questioned the authenticity of their Jewishness, that required them to undergo a conversion before marrying. And, until quite recently, Ethiopian priests could not perform the marriages of Ethiopians.
These and other humiliations resonate powerfully among the young.
Like thousands of other Ethiopians, Eden lost a lot of trust in her new homeland and experienced a personal crisis during the blood-dumping episode of 1996. Until then, the government had collected the blood of Ethiopians. But because many Ethiopians _ not necessarily Jews _ had been exposed to HIV in the Ethiopian capital of Addis Ababa, Israeli officials secretly dumped the donated blood of these immigrants.
After word of the dumping surfaced, Israel faced one of its worst immigrant crises ever.
At school, Eden forced her white classmates, whom she had considered close friends, to discuss the blood-dumping practice. She said each white student sided with the government, saying that most Ethiopian blood probably was infected.
“I realized for the first time that my classroom reflected my society,” she said. “There was racism, and I had to face the fact that this was the society where I live. It was not a pretty sight to see your friends say such things, that, because I’m an Ethiopian Jew, my blood should be dumped. I realized that a lot of people are hypocrites, liars and a lot of other things I will not say. My so-called friends weren’t my real friends. It makes you feel that you’re not wanted here. We’re not a people who shout, but after the blood dumping came to light, many young Ethiopians became angry and rioted. They’re still angry.”
The blood debacle is just one government blunder that skewed the integration of Ethiopian Jews into Israeli society. But a more abstract and broader factor seems to have created other mistakes: With Operation Moses in 1984, the first airlift, and Operation Solomon in 1991, the last major airlift, government agencies, especially the Ministry of Education, dismissed Ethiopian immigrants as “primitives.” Unfortunately, that stereotype has stuck.
I do not believe that authorities were driven by racism per se. They certainly were not led by malice because many of them genuinely want to assist fellow Jews. By and large, they were led by ignorance and by the ineluctable ineptness of bureaucracy. The price, though, has been a series of unintended negative consequences that may take several generations to reverse _ if they can be reversed at all.
Few bureaucrats, for example, spent any time with Ethiopian scholars and other experts who could have warned that placing Ethiopians _ people accustomed to life in villages _ in hotel rooms would be disastrous. The new immigrants could not cook for themselves, wash clothes or perform other family functions that would have made the transition easier.
Then, they were placed in mobile home caravans away from major towns. In many ways, the trailer parks were beneficial because officials could give the Ethiopians concentrated Hebrew classes and other quality-of-life instruction tailored to their needs. But the caravans were, and are, black ghettos. This was a mistake that has bred long-term alienation.
The last of the caravans are to be shut down before year’s end. Even so, Ethiopian Jews will continue to live in mostly segregated communities because they cannot afford upscale properties.
Education questions
This same disconnection from the needs of Ethiopian Jews has resulted in some unfortunate educational strategies. If they had been asked, Ethiopian leaders and experts would have warned that placing most Ethiopian children in vocational schools would be deleterious. Many children could have been placed in college preparatory programs. Worst of all, some smart children were automatically dumped into special education classes where they languished and became disaffected.
These early education blunders have emerged as factors in the poor academic performance of far too many of today’s Ethiopian children. One of the best, and least defensive, studies of how well these children are faring was jointly conducted in 1997 by the Ministry of Education and Culture, the Ministry of Absorption and the Jewish Distribution Committee-Israel. Several of the findings are worth noting:
The school dropout rate among Ethiopian youth is almost double that among the general Jewish population _ 6.2 percent compared with 3.5 percent. The Ethiopian dropout rate is especially high, 10.4 percent, among students who immigrated to Israel before 1990. Among boys in this group, the rate is 9 percent.
A more significant problem is that of “hidden” dropouts: 14 percent of Ethiopian pupils are absent for at least one full day a week for reasons other than vacation or illness. Further, 20 percent changed secondary schools at least once, not because of graduation or relocation.
A large percentage of students receive a failing grade in a major subject _ 19 percent in Hebrew and 32 percent in math. Approximately one-third of them receive no personal academic assistance. Seventy percent, both those already receiving assistance and those not receiving any, want help or additional help with their studies.
Surprisingly, the educational integration of Ethiopian youth who came to Israel before 1991 has been less successful than that of youth who came in 1991 and later. For example, compared with more recent immigrants, dropping out is more common among students who have been in the country longer. A higher percentage of them have difficulty in math, and a smaller number are enrolled in college-bound tracks.
Although the above statistics are grim, they do not represent the full picture of the academic plight of Ethiopian youth. Numbers alone cannot account for the underlying social and cultural factors that also influence outcomes. The study’s findings show, for example, that the “starting point” for Ethiopian children is particularly weak.
Here are two daunting trends: 18 percent of these students come from single-parent families, and approximately 25 percent live in households with six or more children under age 18. Nearly half have fathers age 55 or older, a phenomenon accompanied by low education levels, trouble learning Hebrew and low employment rates. Each factor alone contributes to serious economic distress in Israel’s highly competitive economy.
Fully aware of the Ethiopian Jews’ special education needs, the Israeli government, with assistance from the Joint Distribution Committee and other organizations, initiated several reform measures in the early 1990s. These measures include increased individual assistance, a mediation program that helps parents understand Israeli schools and efforts to tap the leadership of teenagers.
Some of the reforms are showing promise. The integration of Ethiopian students in various academic tracks, for instance, has improved. Sixty-six percent of high schoolers have been integrated into full college-bound programs, 38 percent into academic tracks and 28 percent into vocational tracks. More than 1,500 of Ethiopians attending boarding schools are enrolled at schools with a high academic level. The percentage of students graduating from the 12th grade who are eligible for a diploma has risen sharply. Before reforms, only 7 percent earned certificates. By 1997, however, 20 percent held certificates.
Family impact
While education is destiny for Ethiopians, as it is for other Jews in Israel, it _ along with several other phenomena _ has fostered unintended problems that may never disappear. Israel’s Western-style education system has aided in destroying the patriarchial Ethiopian Jewish family.
In Ethiopia, schooling was family- and village-centered. Parents and elders controlled all areas of learning. The elders, mostly men, were special and were viewed as vessels of wisdom. In Israel, however, Ethiopian children are exposed to the outside world, where strangers are the teachers, where government and civic institutions determine behavior and mete out punishment. The children have responded. They have learned Hebrew and English and are learning the ways of their new homeland.
Meanwhile, the overwhelming majority of the elders are being left behind.
Roles are reversing. In many homes, teenagers are now heads of the household. Many older men and women _ who do not speak Hebrew or English _ have been marginalized to the point that they virtually are “a generation of the wilderness.” Younger women, although still underrepresented in mainstream employment figures, have become increasingly independent, further undermining the traditional roles of the men. Many have their own bank accounts and are otherwise conducting their own business. Some have established social identities of their own.
The results of these and other changes are dramatic and are manifested in subtle ways everywhere Ethiopian Jews live. Old men and women, many in traditional attire, sit on benches staring grimly ahead as they speak in Amharic. Meanwhile, many of their children and grandchildren, dressed in the latest fashions, flash cool hairstyles and jewelry and dream of worlds that are neither Ethiopian nor Israeli.
With each passing day, young people move further away from the ways of their elders. “I love my father and get along with him, but I realize that he and his friends don’t have a culture of having fun,” Eden Tasfay said. “They don’t know what it means to go to a movie and enjoy it. They can’t imagine going to see a play. They have no sense of funness. I don’t know what’s going to happen between the young and old Ethiopian Jews in Israel.”
The racial future
As would be true in the United States, the immigration of people of different skin color always invites issues of race. Nearly two decades after the Ethiopian Jews were brought to Israel, the racial question must be asked: Are Ethiopian Jews the object of racism or racial discrimination in Israel?
For a dispassionate answer, let me defer to the expertise of Steven Kaplan, author and associate professor in the Departments of African Studies and Comparative Religion at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and to Hagar Salamon, also of Hebrew University, where she teaches the culture of Ethiopian Jews. In a recent report, they wrote:
“While it is difficult to make a case for institutionalized racism as a major factor in the Ethiopian encounter with Israeli society, racial prejudice clearly exists on a variety of levels. The Israeli tendency to ascribe to different groups unchanging predetermined “mentalities’ has led the Ethiopians to be characterized as a group with ingrained immutable attributes. While in the case of the Ethiopians such generalizations are often “positive,’ i.e., quiet, polite, gentle (not so with all immigrant groups), they are inherently dangerous since they encourage stereotyping, neglect the individual and replace complex dynamics of cross-cultural communication with an image of an inherently alien “other.’
“A widespread willingness to associate a low level of technology with “primitiveness’ has also resulted in the Ethiopians being labeled by many as “backward’ and naive. Although it is difficult to substantiate claims that there is a clear pattern of racial discrimination against Ethiopians and officials usually act quickly to punish those guilty of such behavior, many Ethiopians have little confidence in the Israeli authorities they encounter. … In the final analysis, situations and policies not perceived by most Israelis as racist may be genuinely understood as such by Ethiopians. Some Ethiopians’ hypersensitivity to racial prejudice is no more justified or realistic than some Israelis’ denials.”
How, then, are the Ethiopian Jews faring in Israel? Again, I defer to a Jew, this time to New York Times commentator William Safire, who has studied the subject and who has special access to those in charge of integrating Ethiopians into Israeli society:
“They are not starving; they are not oppressed; they have roofs over their heads. Some serve in the army; one was elected to the Knesset; but most of the … Ethiopian Jews _ more than half under age 18 _ are not doing well.”
I agree.
Israel’s toughest challenge is to avoid creating a permanent black underclass that will remain forever marginalized and dependent. To prevent this phenomenon from occurring to Ethiopian Jews, Israelis should stop being defensive about what has happened to their Ethiopian brethren.
From the very beginning, when the Beta Israel stepped onto Israeli soil, society’s expectations of absorption were too high. Israeli officials and everyone else needs to learn that transplanting an entire way of life _ a black one into a white one _ is more formidable than anyone ever expected.
+ + +
Newly arrived Ethiopian Jews, such as this mother and child, spend their first months in Israel in “absorption centers.” There, they learn Hebrew, customs and skills that will help them cope much easier with life in their new homeland. _ Media Com (98), Nahariyya, Israel
After nearly two decades in Israel, Ethiopian Jews are trying to establish an authentic identity. Older adults, like those pictured here waiting in line to vote in an election for the first time, hold onto many remnants of village life in their native Ethiopia. The youth, on the other hand, have embraced modern culture. The boy above, sporting a Dallas Cowboy T-shirt, said he has little memory of his native land. The two girls, on a shopping spree at a mall in the coastal town of Hadera, are waiting for friends. _ Bill Maxwell
Eden Tesfay, a 20-year-old who recently completed military service, believes the social and cultural ties between the generations are disintegrating: “I don’t know what’s going to happen between the young and old Ethiopian Jews in Israel.”_ Bill Maxwell
This girl’s placard is a rhetorical question: “Black Jews Are 2nd Class Citizens?!” She is part of a protest against the Israeli government’s dumping of Ethiopian donated blood. Officials suspected that the blood of Ethiopian Jews was infected with HIV.