MAXWELL:  An uneasy solitude

3/9/1997 – Printed in the PERSPECTIVE section of the St Petersburg Times Newspaper

 

MAY SARTON:

A Biography

By Margot Peters

Reviewed by BILL MAXWELL

When May Sarton died at 5:15 p.m. on Sunday, July 16, 1995, thousands of writers, along with tens of thousands of readers, lost a trusted muse. For many, as her biographer Margot Peters describes her, Sarton was “a myth made material, a palpable charge of inspiration.”

Astonishingly, Peters’ is the first biography of Sarton, who wrote 15 books of poetry, 19 novels and 13 memoirs and journals. The reason for this dearth has as much to do with her own wishes as it does with the paradoxical content of her private life and her celebration of solitude _ an often dark world that many critics and academics fear.

Who really understood Sarton, except perhaps her lesbian lovers and a handful of other devoted women who read and discussed her work? Much of what Sarton said and wrote was misunderstood, causing her to live a life of a thousand deaths.

When Peters asked to be Sarton’s biographer, for example, the author replied with the deadpan cynicism that characterizes the body of her work: “Dear Margot Peters, You are not the first and won’t be the last to ask this question. I hope the biog will only be written after my death. There are several books of letters, a new journal still to come out. I’d rather be buried after the death.”

Buried after the death? The meaning of this comment will become clear to those who read May Sarton: A Biography. It is a well-written, 464-page chronicle of Sarton’s early years in pre-World War I Belgium, continuing into and ending during her creative years in the United States. In a style that blends chronology and interpretation, Peters shows Sarton choosing a life in the theater at age 19, signaling the individualism that would become an asset and a liability to an artist who was an amalgam of conflicting sensibilities.

Even at 19, Sarton began to attract the likes of Elizabeth Bowen, Julian Huxley, Rebecca West and Virginia Woolf, a group from which she would draw inspiration and which she, in turn, would inspire. A highlight of the book is that readers can observe Sarton discovering her greatest strength: the journal, a form that let her share a unique spirituality born of a strong feminist perspective and a sense of being the outsider.

But the book is hardly all accolades. On the contrary, it reveals that Sarton may not have been totally honest in her personal narratives when she paints herself as an independent woman who happily embraced solitude.

Peters suggests, through careful analysis, that Sarton was lonely, needy and isolated, that she was an egoist who destroyed friendships and betrayed lovers. Such revelations will disappoint many fans. But they should take heart that the book is honest and does not create new myths and illusions. It depicts Sarton in all of her humanity, as a vulnerable artist who struggled to keep secret parts of her troubled life, as all humans do.

Sarton’s detractors may say, “See, we told you so!” But they, too, should be wary of dismissing the authenticity of Sarton’s life. Peters offers this sobering perspective:

“Her subject matter, the mysteries of the human mind and heart, will not go out of style. Time, careless of fashion, may well treat the best of her lyric poetry favorably. The raging conflicts revealed in the journals are human conflicts and universal: durable fires. If her feminism goes out of style, it will come in again. Her meliorist views are unfashionable only currently. May Sarton will never be considered a great writer. But she is that equally rare phenomenon, an appealing writer whose work has the power to change readers’ lives.”

Much has been made of Sarton’s lesbianism and how it affected her private life and work. In the biography, she explains to a young reader that being a lesbian is one thing. But being publicly honest about it is another matter altogether, requiring courage and a mature understanding that life and art are inextricably linked.

“It takes time to grow into honesty,” she said. “I didn’t come out as a lesbian until. . .I was in my forties. I didn’t want to be labeled too soon. . ..More important, I waited until my parents were dead. I didn’t start living alone until then, either. You shouldn’t live alone until you’ve lived a lot. You have to be enormously disciplined; you have to have something physical to do _ in my case it’s gardening. Contacts are important, but they dissipate the intensity of living, and it’s the intensity that makes the work of art.”

In all, Peters has written a biography that true admirers of Sarton will appreciate. The faint of heart, however, will have trouble dealing with the flaws of an author who, for a half century, served as sister, mother, friend, mentor and lover to tens of thousands of faceless women who, for one reason or another, do not speak for themselves.

Bill Maxwell is an editorial writer and columnist for the Times.