MAXWELL:  Bad blood in Israel

2/25/1996 – Printed in the PERSPECTIVE section of the St Petersburg Times Newspaper

 

The United States is not the only place where people deal with vexing issues of race. Here in the Holy Land, a debate over the secret dumping of Ethiopian blood threatens to damage relations for years to come between traditional Jews recently arrived Ethiopians.

Before arriving here, I was well-acquainted with Israel’s tortured attempt to absorb in a short time nearly a million immigrants mostly from the former Soviet Union and Ethiopia. And from my American vantage point, the secret dumping of this black blood, even though evidence suggests an above average rate of HIV infection among Ethiopian immigrants, suggests that Israelis are racists.

As I spoke with many people, including several Ethiopian teenagers and adults, representatives of the daily Maariv, the newspaper that broke the story, and Yair Tzaban, minister of Immigrants’ Absorption, I realized that racism per se did not cause this debacle. Tzaban, the Knesset member directly responsible for the welfare of the nation’s immigrant population, candidly answered my questions and expressed, as did many other Israelis on this subject, a sense of genuine regret and shame.

Asked if racism was the major problem in the controversy, Tzaban said: “The “good’ absorption of our Ethiopian immigrants is the greatest test of the honor of Jewish society. Ethiopians came to Israel with the biggest cultural (and social) gap of all _ the color of their skin. Skin color remains the hardest element to overcome in the absorption.”

Admitting that medical authorities and government officials had blundered, Tzaban said that the worst mistake was failing to consult with and involve Ethiopian leaders in the blood policy from the outset.

Furthermore, he said that he does not believe that certain pathologies naturally exist among certain ethnic groups: “Differences . . . are more geographic than ethnic. Rejection of blood must be made on the basis of geography and not on ethnicity.” While I listened to him, I wondered if discrimination according to place is any better than discrimination according to ethnicity.

And other important questions cry out. Why, for example, concoct the secret policy at all? Why not _ as the U.S. did in the 1980s when it refused to collect the blood of Haitian immigrants because they had a high incidence of human immunodeficiency virus _ simply refuse Ethiopian blood?

In conversation, I constantly reminded myself that my American orientation to race matters frames my perception, that, while racism is chic in many sectors of U.S. society, it profoundly disturbs most Israelis, who have historical reasons to reject hatred.

I, therefore, believe Dr. Amnon Ben-David, director of the Israeli blood collection agency, when he explains why authorities dumped the blood: “We thought that singling out an ethnic group and telling them to go home would be more offensive and embarrassing.” Other officials, whom I also believe, said that an announced policy of refusing to take the blood would stigmatize Ethiopians, especially soldiers who routinely donate blood with their units.

Ethiopian adults with whom I spoke in Tel Aviv and teens I met at a special school all said that they were more personally “hurt” than angry. A few said that they felt permanently marginalized. Moreover, most said that they have been, and are, victims of racism. They spoke of their 3,000 other countrymen languishing in Ethiopia, unemployment, job and housing discrimination, inferior military assignments and the remote locations of several absorption centers.

Here, I am not proud to say, I pulled rank on a young man who likened Israeli Ethiopian problems to those of American blacks. I pointed out that, while blacks have been in the U.S. for about three centuries, the first Ethiopians came to Israel in 1984 _ not as slaves, but as Jewish citizens under the Law of Return.

Again reminding my listeners that I was speaking from an African-American perspective, I suggested that thousands of other Jewish immigrants since the 1950s have experienced discrimination, alienation and other problems accompanying the severe trauma of permanently leaving one’s birthplace. When the young man insisted that Israel, like America, is a racist society, I reminded him that Israel’s unapologetic, comprehensive affirmative action policy is proof that officials are acting in good faith toward their newest citizens.

Knowing that Ethiopians face discrimination and to ensure their finding decent housing in established communities in the center of cities rather than in distant single-race ghettos, the Ministry of Absorption provides apartment mortgages equivalent in value to 99 percent of the price of the apartment, with a ceiling of $120,000. The mortgage includes a grant of 85 percent of the mortgage amount. The monthly payments are $56.

The government has made similar commitments in education, health care and other vital areas. In fact, officials spend 3 to 5 percent more on Ethiopians than they do on other immigrants.

So despite the dumping of Ethiopian blood, I do not believe that Israel is a racist nation. After all, and I stressed this point with my Ethiopian hosts, Israel is the only country in world history to bring native people out of Africa to freedom.

And the advice that I offered to my Ethiopian brethren: I suggested that they move past the blood controversy and take advantage of their country’s free education and job training and subsidized housing and establish secure lives for themselves and their children.