MAXWELL:  There is wisdom in forgiveness

2/12/1995- Printed in the PERSPECTIVE section of the St Petersburg

 

In 1992, Reginald Denny, who is white, was pulled from the cab of his tractor trailer at Florence and Normandie avenues in South Central Los Angeles. There, two black males savagely beat him. Denny’s beating has become a defining moment of the Rodney King riots.

During the following year, Christopher Wilson, who is black, was vacationing in Tampa where two white males doused him with gasoline and set him on fire. As Wilson rolled on the ground screaming for help and trying to put out the flames consuming his flesh, his tormentors laughed and yelled, “Die, nigger, die.”

Both Denny and Wilson survived and have seen their attackers receive some degree of punishment. I suspect that social historians will portray these two men as tragic victims of the racism and senseless violence of America in the 1990s.

Yes, Denny and Wilson are victims. But they should not be remembered for that circumstance of history alone. They should be remembered for their choice to forgive the warped creatures who tried to kill them, for reaching out to others, for putting their lives back together as best they can.

Their example is worth recalling in 1995 _ the year of talk-radio hatred, religious intolerance and Republican ascendancy. Their example is important because aggression and vengeance have become more accepted as legitimate ways to deal with people with whom we disagree and to punish those who have injured us in some manner.

Matters of race, historical and current conflicts between black and white people, continue to be one of the major areas in which forgiveness is in short supply.

On the national level, the controversy surrounding Francis L. Lawrence, president of Rutgers University, exemplifies the widening gulf between blacks and whites and highlights the need for some give-and-take compassion. Lawrence is under fire for saying during a faculty meeting that because of their “genetic, hereditary background,” blacks perform poorly on college admissions tests.

Realizing that he should not have uttered these words, Lawrence apologized after they became public, and he has done so every day since then. His apologies seem to be genuine in light of his 35 years of implementing programs to recruit and help black students both academically and socially, of hiring black professors and of elevating black administrators. But most black students at Rutgers and most blacks nationwide have rejected Lawrence’s show of remorse and have discounted the significance of his years of good deeds.

The most dramatic moment of this ordeal came during the five-hour meeting on Jan. 10, when the board of governors reaffirmed its support of the president. While angry students were calling for Lawrence’s head, John McCutchen, a local black mechanic, elbowed his way through the crowded room, walked up to the startled president, embraced him and said: “As a child of God, I forgive you.”

Downstairs, students who viewed McCutchen’s gesture on a TV monitor yelled “Sellout!”

While Lawrence’s pleas for forgiveness were being rejected at Rutgers, Dan McCarthy, Yellow Cab Co. general manager in Gainesville was undergoing a similar trial by fire. In late January, two young black males had tried to rob a Yellow Cab driver. During a newspaper interview, McCarthy, who is white, said that the black driver had nearly been robbed because he had violated a company policy of not picking up young black males who do not give a specific address.

After several days of controversy and threats to boycott his company, McCarthy publicly apologized to the “law-abiding African-American men in Gainesville.” Some black leaders accepted the apology, but many others did not, including Ruth Brown, president of the Alachua County branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.

“A stiff apology is an insult,” Brown said. “We’ve been asking for our civil rights for years. This puts us back past Rosa Parks.” When McCarthy approached Brown, she refused to shake his hand. “I don’t want a setup,” she said, pointing to a news photographer. “I don’t want to walk into shaking your hand.”

Rutgers’ students and Gainesville’s black residents have every right to be angry. But they have lost a lot of moral authority and have given up the high road by refusing to forgive. Victims of racial insensitivity cannot afford to be unyielding. They must possess a bigger spirit than those who have injured them. English writer John Dryden was right when he said that “forgiveness to the injured does belong.”

Dryden’s lesson is one that all of us need to relearn. But it is especially important to black people, as the Rutgers and Gainesville cases illustrate. In each, after blacks refused to accept repeated apologies, public sympathy began to shift from the victims to the offender because the world _ rightly or wrongly so _ dislikes the perpetually angry victim.

And, then, we have the huge matter of common sense: Because of the many racial barriers blacks still face and with the imminent dismantling of affirmative action programs nationally, we can ill-afford to constantly reject genuine attempts to reach out to us. When we reciprocate and forgive, we always win. After all, if Christopher Wilson and Reginald Denny can forgive the men who committed the horrible deeds against them, the rest of us should be able to get beyond being eternally insulted by mere words.

I have no way of knowing, but I believe that years from now, Francis Lawrence of Rutgers University, will remember, more than anything else, the black mechanic’s embrace and his words: “I forgive you.”

Bill Maxwell is an editorial writer and columnist for the Times.